Taliban feud over murder of Polish hostage


Pakistani Taliban fighters under the command of Qari Hussain Mehsud stand alongside kidnapped Polish geologist Piotr Stanczak minutes before he was beheaded. Reuters photo.

Two senior Pakistani Taliban leaders had a disagreement over the handling of kidnapped Polish geologist Piotr Stanczak. The disagreement led to Stanczak’s gruesome beheading, which was videotaped by the Taliban and released to the public.

Stanczak was kidnapped in Attock on Sept. 28, 2008, by Taliban fighters under the command of Zakir Mehsud operating from the Arakzai tribal agency. Two of Stanczak’s drivers and one of the Taliban fighters were killed during the kidnapping. Attock is a district in Punjab province that borders the districts of Nowshera, Swabi, and Haripur in the Taliban insurgency-ridden Northwest Frontier Province.

The disagreement occurred between Baitullah Mehsud, the leader of the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan, and Qari Hussain Mehsud, a key lieutenant of Baitullah’s, according to a report from the region.

Baitullah sought to use Stanczak to obtain the release of several of his followers, while Qari Hussain, who had custody of Stanczak, sought the release of four members of the radical Lashkar-e-Jhangvi and an Uzbek, a Taliban source told The News. The move triggered Qari to execute Stanczak.

“A day before the beheading of the engineer [Stanczak], Baitullah sent his men to bring the captive but the Qari group did not agree and beheaded the captive the next day,” Mohammed, a Taliban spokesman for Zakir Mehsud told The News. “This forced Qari to behead the Polish engineer.” Zakir Mehsud is one of Qari’s lieutenants in the city of Darra Adam Khel in the Arakzai tribal agency.

Mohammed quoted Zakir as saying Qari’s decision to behead Stanczak was sound “as it would create fear amongst the nonbelievers. If we keep on sending such gifts to the Europeans and others, they would soon be compelled to flee the region,” Mohammed said. “If God wishes, people would see more and more beheadings of nonbelievers in the future.”

Hakimullah Mehsud, the Taliban commander in Arakzai, Khyber, and Peshawar who is behind the attacks on NATO’s supply lines in northwestern Pakistan, had hoped to get a teenager to behead Stanczak but the plan was called off due to the short amount of time to find a child, Mohammed said.

Several times in the past, the Taliban in both Pakistan and Afghanistan have released videotapes of children and teenagers beheading captives.

The report of the disagreement between Baitullah and Qari became public just two days after a roadside bomb wounded Mullah Noor Sayyed Mehsud, a deputy of Baitullah’s, and killed another Taliban commander and wounded another leader. Noor was leaving a meeting of senior Taliban commanders in Makeen, Baitullah’s home town. There is no evidence that the two incidents are linked, but Qari is one of the few people who could pull off such an attack.

“The beheading of the Polish engineer by the Qari group will further deepen the already existing differences between the TTP [Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan or the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan] and Qari Hussain,” Mohammed said.

Baitullah and Qari Hussain clashed in June 2007 after the latter’s foot soldiers launched a series of violent attacks on police in the tribal areas. Qari Hussain’s followers conducted beheadings and assassinations of tribal leaders in South Waziristan and the settled district of Tank. He was behind the attack on the home of the political agent of Khyber Agency, which resulted in the death of the agent’s six family members and seven guests.

The incidents caused friction between the two Taliban leaders as Qari Hussain failed to obtain permission to conduct his campaign of terror. Baitullah retaliated by capturing 17 of Qari Hussain’s followers and threatening to kill them. The rift between the two leaders was quickly smoothed over during the summer of 2007, however, after the Taliban went on the offensive against the Pakistani military, government, and civilians in July of that year.

Background on Qari Hussain Mehsud

Qari Hussain Mehsud is a senior deputy to Pakistani Taliban commander Baitullah Mehsud and an ally of al Qaeda as well as the Lashkar-e-Jahangvi and other extremist groups. He runs camps in South Waziristan that train children to become suicide bombers. Children as young as seven years old are indoctrinated to wage jihad in Pakistan and Afghanistan, a video taken at one of his camps in Spinkai showed.

The Pakistani military demolished Qari’s suicide nursery during a short offensive against the Taliban in Spinkai in January 2008. The military launched a short operation after Taliban forces commanded by Baitullah overran two military outposts and conducted attacks against other forts and military convoys in the tribal agency.

The military seized numerous documents and training materials in the demolished camp. In May, a senior Pakistani general described the previous camp as a suicide “factory” for children.

The Pakistani military reported that Qari was killed in January 2008, based on intercepted Taliban communications. The military later reiterated that claim during the tour of the Spinkai camp on May 18, 2008.

Five days later, Hussain mocked the military during a press conference held at a government school building in South Waziristan. “I am alive, don’t you see me?” Hussain taunted. Hussain rebuilt his child training camps in South Waziristan sometime in the spring or summer of 2008.

In January 2009, Qari openly held a press conference in Peshawar, the capital of the Northwest Frontier Province. During the press conference, he released a 40-minute propaganda tape showing statements of suicide bombers and the aftermath of their attacks inside Pakistan. Child suicide bombers are shown praising suicide attacks and saying attacking infidels is their religious duty.

“Suicide bombers are the atomic weapons of Muslims because Muslims do not have the latest weapons to fight enemies who are committing atrocities against Muslims in Kashmir, Palestine, Afghanistan and Iraq,” one of the young men said.

Qari’s suicide bombers took credit for attacks against Pakistani security and intelligence forces, including the March 2008 double suicide attack on the headquarters of the Federal Investigation Agency in Lahore (26 killed and more than 160 wounded) and the September 2007 attack on an Inter-Service Intelligence agency bus and a military bazaar in Rawalpindi (25 killed, 68 wounded).

Bill Roggio is a Senior Fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and the Editor of FDD's Long War Journal.



  • jayc says:

    al qaeda inspired? check the goon on the rights pants leg and then read bill roggio’s lashkar al zil article. interesting.

  • khurram says:

    I am Pakistani Muslim.
    I saw the video. and would like to say some thing about it that i disapprove that kind of peoples how are useing the word of islam for getting own personal interests or organizations. And they think they are doing good for islam and muslims. This is not the actual way, which that kind of people, they are doing. They are useing the methods of terrorism. In Muslims history, we cant see that kind of persons, Being a Muslim i dont know who are they who say we are muslims. where are they came from between muslims.
    They are not muslims. They are really terrorist who are doing work against Muslims and muslim countries.
    So, Being a Muslim i am doing request to the reall Muslims think about it and try to stop them who are createing problems for Muslims and the non-muslim.

  • Raj Kumar says:

    Sorry khurram but Islamic history is littered with enough evidence of how Islam has treated non believers from the earliest inception of your faith.
    And while this forum is not the right place to discuss personal faiths I will say that I see no attempt at any sort of ‘reform’ within the Islamic faith and it is this which leads me to believe that Islam needs to be treated with the same kind of treatment that was given to the old Soviet Union.

  • flyonthwall says:

    These two observations could launch a rich and dynamic conversation, but I agree, probably not consistent with longwarjournal guidelines. Any ideas of a place where these two points could be expanded? I can offer another site, but need Bill R and the other site host’s OK.

  • Neo says:

    Raj Kumar,
    Just a suggestion, but regulars here might want to give newcomers a little space to express themselves without us jumping into instant debate with them over some point. I am glad to see a few Pakistani’s show up and acknowledge that there are big problems, without instantly putting them on the defensive.
    That being said, you do have a point. Muslims do have a tendency to be very selective in their appreciation of their own history. There isn’t a lot of space for any sort of critical appreciation of the past.

  • remoteman says:

    Send him to Rantburg. He’ll get an education there.

  • AMac says:

    Thanks for visiting and making those points. Prior posters are right, further discussion of them likely wouldn’t conform to the LWJ commenting guidelines.

  • David M says:

    The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the blog post From the Front: 02/13/2009 News and Personal dispatches from the front and the home front.


Islamic state



Al shabaab

Boko Haram