« Hafiz Saeed preaches jihad in Kashmir | Main | Statement on Taliban site says they'll talk, but... »




Army releases report on battle at Combat Outpost Keating



The US Army has released the executive summary of the report on the Taliban assault on Combat Outpost Keating in October 2009 that nearly saw the base overrun. The abandonment of Keating and other remote outposts less than two weeks after the assault gave the Taliban uncontested control of several rural districts in Nuristan.

I've received the executive summary from ISAF Public Affairs. The full summary is posted below. There is one problem I can see in the report, and it is in the final paragraph. The military claims the base was destroyed before it was abandoned. But as the Taliban video above shows, they found quite a bit left behind to use.

Executive Summary - AR 15-6 Investigation re: Complex Attack on COP Keating - 3 Oct 09

On 3 October 2009, Soldiers of Bravo Troop, 3rd Squadron, 61st Cavalry, repelled an enemy force of 300 Anti-Afghan Forces (AAF) fighters, preserving their combat outpost and killing approximately 150 of the enemy fighters. US forces sustained eight killed in action and 22 wounded, all but three of whom returned to duty after the attack. The Soldiers distinguished themselves with conspicuous gallantry, courage, and bravery under the heavy enemy fire that surrounded them.

Combat Outpost (COP) Keating, originally established as a base for a Provincial Reconstruction Team in 2006, was located deep in a bowl in Nuristan Province, surrounded by high ground, with limited overwatch protection from nearby Observation Post (OP) Fritsche. The mission for COP Keating during the rotation of B Troop was unclear to the Soldiers of B Troop who understood counterinsurgency doctrine and the need to engage with and protect the local population. But owing to limited manpower and tactical reach off of the compound, the mission devolved into one of base defense and by mid-2009 there was no tactical or strategic value to holding the ground occupied by COP Keating. As a result, the chain of command decided to close the remote outpost as soon as it could. Originally scheduled for closure in July-August 2009, COP Keating's withdrawal was delayed when the assets required to backhaul base supplies were diverted to support intense brigade-level operations in Barg-e Matal in support of ANSF forces. Similarly, ISR assets that could have given the Soldiers at COP Keating better situational awareness of their operational environment were reprioritized to support Barge-e Matal as well as the search for a missing US Soldier in the south.

The delayed closing of COP Keating is important as it contributed to a mindset of imminent closure that served to impede improvements in force protection on the COP. There were inadequate measures taken by the chain of command, resulting in an attractive target for enemy fighters. Over time, and without raising undue concern within the US intelligence system, the enemy conducted numerous probing attacks, learning the tactics, techniques and procedures of B Troop, and pinpointing location of weapons systems and key infrastructure and material, such as generators and barracks.

Compounding the situation for the Soldiers on COP Keating, intelligence assessments became desensitized to enemy actions over several months. During the five months of B Troop's deployment to COP Keating, the enemy launched approximately 47 attacks - three times the rate of attacks experienced by their predecessors. On several occasions intelligence reports in advance of an attack indicated there was a large enemy force that would strike, but the attack that followed generally consisted of a few number of fighters who used indirect and small arms fire for an engagement that averaged five to ten minutes in duration. Owing to this experience with the enemy in vicinity of COP Keating, the perception prevailed that reports of massing enemy forces were exaggerated and improbable. The focus became the enemy's most likely, rather than his most dangerous course of On 3 October 2009, the Soldiers of B Troop awoke to a previously unseen volume of enemy fire, commencing at approximately 0558 hours, and coming from the high ground surrounding the COP. A simultaneous enemy attack against OP Fritsche limited mortar fire support from that location. Enemy fighters applied the information gathered from probing attacks and immediately inflicted casualties on the COP's guard force and suppressed COP Keating's primary means of fire support, its 60mm and 120mm mortars. Afghan National Army (ANA) soldiers on the eastern side of the compound failed to hold their position, and enemy AAF fighters penetrated the COP Keating perimeter at three locations.

Continuing to fight under the heavy enemy indirect and direct fire from superior tactical
positions, and suffering a loss of power to the tactical operations center (TOC) when enemy forces destroyed the main power generator, B Troop withdrew to a tight internal perimeter. With critical supporting fires from USAF close air support (CAS) and AH-64 Apache helicopter close combat aviation (CCA) fires, the junior officers and NCOs regained the initiative and fought back during the afternoon hours to regain control of COP Keating. The Soldiers, aided now by continuous fires from supporting aviation units, engaged the enemy fighters who had breached the compound, killing at least four of them, and reestablished control of key buildings. B Troop and the air support neutralized AAF positions in the local Afghan National Police (ANP) station and mosque in the nearby village of Urmol, as well as in the surrounding hills.

The Soldiers of B Troop demonstrated courage, bravery, and heroism as they inflicted over 150 casualties on enemy forces and reestablished their perimeter. In the process, the Soldiers embodied the Warrior Ethos and recovered all friendly casualties. As evening fell on the night of 3 October 2009, COP Keating remained solidly under US control and enemy forces had suffered a severe tactical defeat. Eight American Soldiers made the ultimate sacrifice defending their outpost and their fellow Soldiers.

Over the following days B Troop withdrew its forces from COP Keating, pursuant to the TFMountain Warrior plan to evacuate tactically untenable COPs and OPs, and destroyed what remained of the camp on 6 October 2009 to prevent enemy use.



READER COMMENTS: "Army releases report on battle at Combat Outpost Keating"

Posted by Bill Hocter at February 6, 2010 6:57 PM ET:

I'm sure there must be a good reason to establish a combat outpost in a "bowl" surrounded by high ground. Perhaps it made a convenient landing area for helos. Next time, though, let's grab some high ground too!

Posted by charley at February 6, 2010 9:54 PM ET:

earlier reports in the press asked this same question with answer being that the village was in the low ground along the river/creek/intermittent stream. (so in effect, the original rationale was to be closer to the people.)

Posted by Graeme Rymill at February 7, 2010 5:48 AM ET:

It is all very well to want to be "near the people" and occupy the low ground. However it isvital to have sufficient soldiers to occupy the adjacent high ground as well. It comes down to having the resources to do the job.

Posted by gandalf at February 7, 2010 1:45 PM ET:

The enemy gained a significant tactical advantage early in the attack. As the sun rose, the enemy created numerous smoky fires thoughout the valley. The haze was so thick that CAS couldn't acquire targets and thermal imaging overhead was obscured.

Many small arms and ammo was captured by the enemy when they overran one of their primary objectives, the armory.

Hopefully we gained from this experience.

Posted by Render at February 7, 2010 3:30 PM ET:

The belted 40mm (for the M-19) and the Claymore mines are unquestionably of US origin.

The RPG warheads are not of US origin. They (at least one) appear to have homemade long stand-off AP type fuses. ANA doesn't have much need for AP RPG warheads, Talib do.

SNOW
BOUND,
R

Posted by Alex at February 7, 2010 5:16 PM ET:

This article has been linked to in Frontier Outlook: http://www.frontieroutlook.com/?p=201

Posted by Dan O'Shea at February 7, 2010 5:49 PM ET:

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."

George Santayana
Vol. I, Reason in Common Sense

-------------------------

Read:

Sappers in the Wire: The Life and Death of Firebase Mary Ann

Keith William Nolan

ISBN-10: 0890966540

-------------------------

From Publishers Weekly

The battle took place on a remote hilltop in Quang Tin Province during the latter days of "Vietnamization," when open defiance of orders was common among GIs. What happened at Firebase Mary Ann the night of March 27-28, 1971, was, according to the author of this riveting account, the U.S. Army's "most blatant and humiliating defeat in Vietnam." That night, 50 sappers of the 409th Viet Cong Main Force Battalion, wearing nothing but shorts, slipped through the base's barbed wire without alerting a single sentry, killed 30 GIs and wounded 82 others. Relying on interviews with survivors and recently declassified documents, Nolan reconstructs the assault from start to finish, showing how a demoralized American unit (1st Battalion, 46th Infantry, Americal Division) was crushed, despite the heroic actions of a few individuals. He traces the chain-of-command process by which the defeat ruined the careers of the division and battalion commanders. By the author of The Magnificent Bastards, this is a perceptive study of poor leadership and combat demoralization. It is also a terrific battle book.

-------------------------

PS I was a MACV advisor dealing with another battle in the same province at the same time, dropping illumination cannisters out of the back of a huey.

-------------------------