Pakistani general dismisses ‘media hype’ over North Waziristan operation

Lieutenant General Asif Yasin Malik, the commander of XI Corps, which directs military operations in Pakistan’s northwest, poured a bit of cold water today on the prospects of an operation in North Waziristan. In an interview with the press, Malik described the reports of a impending operation as “media hype” and said Pakistan would launch an operation “when it is in our national interest militarily.” From Dawn:

Lieutenant General Asif Yasin Malik, the corps commander supervising all military operations in the northwestern province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, told reporters: “We will undertake operation in North Waziristan when we want to.”

“There has been a lot of media hype about the operation,” said Malik in the Mohamad Gat area of tribal district Mohmand, where the military flew reporters to show off apparent progress in battles against home-grown Taliban.

“We will undertake such an operation when it is in our national interest militarily,” the general said, describing North Waziristan as “calm and peaceful as it was weeks ago”.

Asked whether there was a need for such an operation, he said only: “Maybe ultimately we will go to North Waziristan”.

General Malik’s comments come one day after Pakistani military officials told Dawn that any operation would be limited in scope and would target only the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan.

In background interviews with Dawn, military commanders ruled out the possibility of a full-scale operation like the one launched in South Waziristan and said it was ‘unfeasible’ because of difference in ground realities.

South Waziristan, they said, was a “no-go area” when they launched a major military offensive in October 2009 to flush out terrorists. “But the northern part has a massive presence of military and there are peace pacts with tribes that cannot be ignored.”

The army has a division of troops stationed in the agency with headquarters in Miramshah and brigade level command centres in Mirali, Dattakhel and Razmak. The other factors preventing an all-out assault are its inhospitable terrain and geographic isolation.

A senior officer said: “The operation will be very selective and intelligence led.”

The military assessment is that there are only two to three pockets having terrorist presence which need to be cleared.

Although the military officials didn’t explicitly talk about sparing the Haqqanis, one can make out from the conversation that there is still no shift in policy about the group. They are of the opinion that the Haqqani network is more of a myth and the threat posed by it has been exaggerated.

A major target, it is said, will be Tehrik-i-Taliban militants who took refuge in North Waziristan after having been dislodged from south. “It will indeed be a big achievement if we succeed in neutralising some of the suicide bomber training centres,” an officer said.

Something that lends further credence to the possibility of a very limited scope of the operation is that military commanders aren’t expecting a major displacement from the region. On the contrary, press reports have suggested that aid agencies were directed several weeks ago to prepare for exodus of over 350,000 people from the area.

I am now going to refer you back to my post from May 30 that provided a snapshot analysis of what a military operation in North Waziristan might look like. Note I said that if the Pakistani military does move, it would be a “limited operation” and would exclude the “good Taliban” factions:

1. The primary target is the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan. This does not include Taliban groups such as the Haqqani Network and Bahadar’s Taliban faction. This would be similar to the limited operation in South Waziristan in the fall of 2009, when the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan was targeted but Mullah Nazir’s forces were left intact (Nazir, who recently affirmed he is an al Qaeda commander, openly controls half of South Waziristan to this day, and continues to shelter al Qaeda and other terror groups).

And:

6. As noted above, the Haqqani Network and Bahadar’s Taliban faction, both of which are viewed by Pakistan’s military and intelligence services as “good Taliban,” will be spared, despite the fact that these two groups have violated a two-year-old peace agreement with the military that prohibited them from hosting the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan, al Qaeda, and other allied terror groups. The Haqqanis and Bahadar’s Taliban faction have violated this agreement from the very beginning, but the Pakistani state has refused to hold the groups accountable.

The Pakistani military, if it does act, will do just enough to be able to placate the US by being able to say it has moved into North Waziristan, while not actually doing enough to reduce the threat the so-called “good Taliban” pose by sheltering al Qaeda and other terror groups as well as launching attacks into Afghanistan.

Bill Roggio is a Senior Fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and the Editor of FDD's Long War Journal.

Are you a dedicated reader of FDD's Long War Journal? Has our research benefitted you or your team over the years? Support our independent reporting and analysis today by considering a one-time or monthly donation. Thanks for reading! You can make a tax-deductible donation here.

Tags: , ,

7 Comments

  • Paul D says:

    “We will undertake such an operation when it is in our national interest militarily,” the general said, describing North Waziristan as “calm and peaceful as it was weeks ago”.
    Says it all as too many Pak assets in North Waziristan to make it worth their while attacking!
    How is multiple sucicide training camps calm and peaceful?

  • Jawed Akhtar says:

    They will only go for action in North Waziristan after they have removed HAQQANI militants to safety….Not before that…..Presently, they might be looking for safe houses, in South Waziristan, Quetta, Karachi, Abbotabad, etc. Give them some time……….And also some funds to buy houses, cars, food, etc….

  • kp says:

    “They will only go for action in North Waziristan after they have removed HAQQANI militants to safety”

    All 5,000 of them? That might be a challenge to do whilst the CIA drones are watching overhead and looking for targets. You are not going to hide “half a divsion” easily in KP or the FATA. These are local Pashtun not foreign fighters. If they do move them then the HN attacks will drop off and the Americans will know they’ve moved (and not destroyed because they can observe that). The National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency will be looking for where they got moved too and what happens in NW and surrounding areas. We may even end up with USOC on the ground (with Pakistans permission) in joint ops. If they end up somewhere else in Pakistan the Pakistani’s are in for a world of hurt from the US.

    I disagree with Bill on this one. The Pakistani’s are between a rock and hard place. I think the US (through Mullen and Clinton) has given them a clear set of expectations for a thorough NW operation that includes HN and the TTP. If they fail to deliver then the Pakistani’s will be in for a hard time (less aid and possibly more raids into Pakistan?). And made clear that the they want the Top 4 HVTs which, interestingly. didn’t include the TTP’s Haikimullah Mehsud because the US knows that Pakistan already wants to get HM and his org. And perhaps that the TTP are a spent force. The operation may be focused but it will be focused on rooting out the targets we want.

    The HN and other “good Taliban” have also got to wonder what the Pakistani government are up to. They listen to their (deniable?) ISI friends but do they know what’s happening? Do they move and open themselves up to the CIA? Do they hope the Pak Army is not going to engage them?

    I suspect Lt. Gen. Malik is out of the loop on this (despite his rank). Alternatively this might all be for public show (never underestimate theater in Pakistan) that “we are standing up to the evil Americans”.

    The other point (that may not be obvious to some) is this is not a case of Pakistani Army/FC moving into NW after having abandonded the place. They already have a garrison presence in the big towns (like Miram Shah … take a look at Google Earth to find the big Army base not far from the airport … that was CIA’s Shawshank base location). They don’t seem to have much of a presence outside of the major towns and seem to have no intention of stopping the locals from engaging in insurgent activity.It seems the CIA has done that by reducing the presence of training in the open even in Miram Shah that happened a couple of years ago. That’s the real issue.

    Ultimately we’ll see what unfolds but I think the Pakistanis have run out of excuses that the US will believe.

  • naresh c. says:

    “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” -Albert Einstein
    Hooray! More F16s to Pakistan so that it can threaten India and Afghanistan even more. More billions of dollars of aid in the bottomless begging bowl of Pakistan. Send John Kerry on the next flight to Islamabad so that he can sound even more apologetic.

  • Mr T says:

    “But the northern part has a massive presence of military and there are peace pacts with tribes that cannot be ignored.”
    I like that part. Can not be ignored? The other side ignores them all the time and… oh yeah, the Paks ignore them all the time too. It is a sham that is really wearing thin.

  • Tim says:

    Read this extensive piece about Jihadi infiltration of the Pakistan Armed Forces:
    //www.rediff.com/news/slide-show/slide-show-1-how-jihadis-are-infiltrating-pak-armed-forces/20110602.htm
    I am not surprised Pakistan won’t attack N.Waziristan. That could start a civil war…not only in the country, but in the army as well!

  • sajid says:

    bravo its a good news that militant will be no more in north waziristan.

Iraq

Islamic state

Syria

Aqap

Al shabaab

Boko Haram

Isis