Pakistan’s President Musharraf resigns office

musharraf.jpg

Former President and General Pervez Musharraf.

President Pervez Musharraf, the longtime military leader of Pakistan and erstwhile ally of the US in the war against Islamic extremists, announced his resignation after months of political battles with the recently elected government of Pakistan. Musharraf’s resignation pre-empted an expected impeachment battle that was to begin this week.

Musharraf appeared on Pakistani television announcing his resignation. “After viewing the situation and consulting legal advisers and political allies, with their advice I have decided to resign,” he said. “I leave my future in the hands of the people.”

Rumors of Musharraf’s resignation appeared late last week after senior members of the military and his political advisers floated the idea to the press. The Army is believed to have asked Musharraf to step down. Musharraf’s aides were in negotiations with the Pakistan’s coalition government last week. Theses talks were facilitated by the US, Britain, and Saudi Arabia, and it is believed Musharraf received immunity in exchange for stepping down.

Musharraf made numerous political enemies since taking power in a military coup in 1999. He overthrew the government of Nawaz Sharif, the leader of the Pakistan Muslim League – Nawaz (PML-N). Sharif went in exile, along with former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, the leader of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP).

After the al Qaeda attacks on the US on Sept. 11, 2001, Musharraf was issued an ultimatum by then Assistant Secretary of State Richard Armitage to target al Qaeda’s support network. Armitage said the US would bomb Pakistan “back to the stone age” if the country did not support US actions in Afghanistan and dismantle al Qaeda’s safe havens in Pakistan.

Musharraf’s cooperation with the US infuriated Pakistan’s Islamists political parties as well as supporters of the Taliban and jihadi groups in the military and the Inter-Services Intelligence, Pakistan’s shadowy spy agency. Pakistan has used the Taliban and various al Qaeda-linked jihadi groups as “strategic depth” against India, Pakistan’s enemy to the east.

Pakistan’s security and intelligence services rounded up hundreds of Taliban and al Qaeda foot soldiers and scores of senior leaders, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the architect of the Sept. 11 attacks. Pakistan often claims more than 700 al Qaeda operatives have been captured over the past seven years.

But Pakistan has had a spotty record in keeping al Qaeda and Taliban operatives and leaders in custody. Senior Taliban commanders such as Mullah Obaidullah have been exchanged for captured Pakistani military and governmental officials. Sufi Mohammed, a senior extremist leader who sent more than 10,000 fighters into Afghanistan, was released in exchange for settling a “peace deal” in Bajaur and Malakand. The government dropped charges against radical Lal Masjid cleric Maulana Abdul Aziz and 450 students after they participated in an armed uprising in the capital of Islamabad. And al Qaeda operatives, such as Rashid Rauf, have escaped capture under very unusual circumstances.

Musharraf sealed his fate after declaring martial law in November 2007. Done under the auspices of fighting the Taliban and al Qaeda, Musharraf instead used his power to dismiss the justices of the Supreme Court and pack the court with his supporters. Parliamentary and provincial elections were suspended. He modified the constitution to allow him to remain in power and rounded up his political enemies in the PPP and PML-N. Benazir Bhutto was placed under house arrest just weeks after triumphantly returning from exile.

Musharraf lifted martial law in January and parliamentary and provincial elections were held in late February. The PPP won the most seats, followed by the PML-N. The Pakistan Muslim League – Qaid, Musharraf’s political party, took a distant fourth. The Muttahida Majlis-e-Amil, or MMA, the pro-Taliban Islamist party, was also routed. Talks of impeachment and the removal of Musharraf began immediately.

Pakistan and the future fight against al Qaeda and the Taliban

The resignation of Musharraf now calls into question Pakistan’s role in the Long War and the fight against al Qaeda and the Taliban. Musharraf, for all of his faults, has long been seen as an ally of the US against the rise of Islamic extremists in Pakistan’s border areas.

The United States has invested its political capital in supporting Musharraf while transitioning power to a secular government, presumed to have been led by Bhutto, that is capable of fighting the Taliban. Musharraf, who was Chief of Staff of the Army, was to remain as president while the Army would be led by General Ashfaq Kiyani, a protege of Musharraf and the former head of the Inter-Services Intelligence. But Bhutto was killed by the Taliban in December 2007, and now Musharraf has been removed from the picture, leaving Pakistan’s political parties fighting over control of the government.

The Pakistani coalition government of the PPP and the PML-N has focused enormous energy in the efforts to eject Musharraf from the presidency, while the security situation in the Northwest Frontier Province and the tribal agencies has deteriorated rapidly. The federal government has largely deferred to the Awami National Party, a secular Pashtun party that won elections in the Northwest Frontier Province, to make policy with respect to the Taliban.

The provincial government, with the backing of the federal government, has signed multiple peace agreements with the Taliban in the tribal areas and in the settled districts of the Northwest Frontier Province. The Taliban have responded by increasing attacks and consolidating power in the region. The government then launched ineffective offensives that purported to oust the Taliban from power but only ceded more regions to the extremists. These policies are only likely to continue now that Musharraf is out of power.

The PPP and the PML-N are now likely to jockey for power in Pakistan, as the office of the presidency is now up for grabs. Nawaz and Asif Ali Zardari, the leader of the PPP and the husband of Bhutto, are believed to be eying the office.

“Sharif, Zardari, and [Prime Minister Yousuf Raza] Gilani are the most powerful figures in Pakistani politics now,” Daveed Gartenstein-Ross, the vice president of research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, told The Long War Journal.

Sharif has long been considered a sympathizer of the Taliban and is rumored to have accepted bribe money from al Qaeda. Sharif has also advocated an end to military operations in the Northwest Frontier Province.

“Gilani will try to strengthen the office of prime minister,” Gartenstein-Ross said, noting that prior to Musharraf’s coup, the office of the prime minister was the seat of power in Pakistan.

While machinations of Pakistan’s’ political parties play out over the next weeks and months, al Qaeda, the Taliban, and allied terror groups are likely to continue to metastasize in the Northwest Frontier Province and the tribal areas. There are 157 training camps and more than 400 support locations in the region, senior US military and intelligence officials told The Long War Journal. Last month, Prime Minister Gilani was told more than 8,000 foreign fighters are present in the tribal areas.

For background on Pakistan’s political crisis, see:

Pakistan: Musharraf suspends constitution, declares state of emergency, Nov. 3, 2007

Musharraf, pro-Taliban party routed in Pakistan’s election, Feb. 19, 2008

Descent into Appeasement, May 31, 2008

Pakistan: A Dangerous Neighbor, Aug. 6, 2008

Bill Roggio is a Senior Fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and the Editor of FDD's Long War Journal.

Are you a dedicated reader of FDD's Long War Journal? Has our research benefitted you or your team over the years? Support our independent reporting and analysis today by considering a one-time or monthly donation. Thanks for reading! You can make a tax-deductible donation here.

Tags:

9 Comments

  • TS Alfabet says:

    Now things get interesting.
    Surely there must be some tribal chiefs in the frontier provinces who are getting sick of being treated as 3rd class citizens in their own lands by Al Qaeda. It is hard to believe that AQ and the Taliban have not managed to alienate some tribe or chieftain. Does anyone have any hard information in this regard? Bill? DJ?
    If only we could find some with territory right on the Afghan border, we could provide all the military and logistical muscle needed to turn one of these chiefs into a force to be reckoned with. Is this a pipe dream?

  • Ali Azizi says:

    The only reason Sharif has been “sympathetic” to the Taliban has been political expediency. Any attempts to portray him as truly sympathetic with extremists stems from a very weak understanding of Pakistani policy.

  • GM Earnest says:

    I agree with Mr. Azizi regarding Mr. Sharif. During these past few weeks, with a dark cloud hanging over Gen. Musharraf’s last days as President, the Pakistani military has taken many hits and dished out stinging retaliations in spite of the much publicized softness of the new civilian government.
    We can only hope the broad swath of Pakistanis don’t want their country ruined by Taleban and al Qaeda fanatics.

  • jayc says:

    Regarding Mr. Musharraf’s departure, perhaps the Pakistanis should take wise counsel in the old Irish saying: Better the Devil that you know, than the one you don’t.”

  • Bill Roggio says:

    If you think cozying up the the Taliban for “political expediency” is a good idea, then that is frightening indeed. There is plenty of information publicly available on Nawaz’s positions on the Taliban. Most disturbing is the allegation he received bribe money from Osama bin Laden. My sources are terrified at the prospect that Nawaz will rise in prominence in Pakistani politics.

  • RR says:

    I am not sure what is happening next. Nobody really seems to be in charge of Pakistan, and both of these feudal leaders are so focused on figuring out how they can be #1, that everything else is being ignored. Musharraf united them, and now he’s gone.
    Big issues are economy tanking, lawyers want the judges to be reinstated, Zardari/Sharif/ISI/Miltary power issues, open rebellion/power grab by the Taliban, upset US, and upset India. Not to mention how corrupt both leaders are (Mr. 10% and I took a bribe from Bin Laden) and they treat the country as a their own personal fiefdom.

  • bard207 says:

    TS Alfabet,
    Surely there must be some tribal chiefs in the frontier provinces who are getting sick of being treated as 3rd class citizens in their own lands by Al Qaeda. It is hard to believe that AQ and the Taliban have not managed to alienate some tribe or chieftain. Does anyone have any hard information in this regard?
    It will take the presence of Pakistani troops to spur more tribals to standup against the Taliban and similar militants. The combination of Army reluctance to do it and political instability makes it difficult.
    Editorial: Going, going, gone
    Second Editorial: Local resistance to Taliban
    After the people of Buner, Upper and Lower Dir in the Malakand Division surrounded the Taliban terrorists and put them under an ultimatum to leave their territory, it is the people in Bajaur who have now stood up to the marauding activities of the “militants”

  • Buff52 says:

    Regarding the anti-Taliban and anti-AlQuaeda Pakistani local tribesmen, would it be practical for U.S. Army Special Forces to “train” and equip them?
    Wasn’t the original Special Forces twelve man “A” Team suppose to, in a clandestine manner, train up a force of about 1200 local people to fight their oppressors?

  • colawman says:

    Wasn’t the original Special Forces twelve man “A” Team suppose to, in a clandestine manner, train up a force of about 1200 local people to fight their oppressors?
    Buff,
    This is still a part of an ODA’s mission. Their hands are full training up Afghan and Iraqi armies as well as DA missions. They are doing what you suggest in other parts of the world in this GWOT. Perhaps their Op Tempo is exactly why they are increasing the size of the SF Groups.

Iraq

Islamic state

Syria

Aqap

Al shabaab

Boko Haram

Isis