Zarqawi Successors

Conflicting reports of the status of al Qaeda commander in Iraq Abu Musab al-Zarqawi abound. Egyptian blogger Hammorabi reports Zarqawi is dead and his family in Jordan is preparing his funeral (note: Hammorabi has been accurate in the past, he led on the news of Zarqawi being wounded). Al Qaeda in Iraq claims all is well, and Zarqawi is fine, just fine, thank you.

Recently we’ve looked at the potential for internecine warfare between the various al Qaeda factions in Iraq as well as a few of the potential successors to Zarqawi’s throne. Questions remain about the impact Zarqawi’s loss would have on al Qaeda in Iraq. The Counterterrorism Blog links to a transcript of a pair of interviews with counterterror expert Steve Emerson on Fox News who addresses these issues. He reiterates several points we have made, that Zarqawi is a ‘fighting commander’, his death would have a noticeable impact on the organization and will potentially create a power struggle for ascension:

EMERSON: Well again, it’s hard to predict [the impact of Zarqawi’s death] . My feeling is that because he’s such an on-the-ground commander, and because he’s so control- oriented, that this could have a major, major effect in disrupting the insurgencies’ coordinations and their operations. I think that Zarqawi was really the glue that held the organization together. It was Zarqawi, Zarqawi, Zarqawi. Not like Bin Laden, who had a whole chain of command that he could rely on. Here, there’s really no one to replace him.

In fact, there’s been a whole series of denials today about who in fact is going to take his place. Denying, in fact, that one person would take his place, affirming that he would, and then denying that he would. So there’s really now a major fight for ascension. I think this could have a major disruptive effect on their ability to launch attacks with such pinpoint precision as they’ve done in the past.

Zarqawi is a key to the organization because of his contacts, stature and operational skill. He has established ties in the region over the course of years with the creation of Jamaat al-Tawhid wa’l-Jihad, links to Ansar al-Islam and contacts with Saddam’s security services. He ran a terrorist training camp in Afghanistan and is an associate of Osama bin Laden (See Dan Darling’s full dossier on Zarqawi and his multifacited connections and skills). This is the ‘glue’ that holds together the various domestic and foreign factions of al Qaeda in Iraq. For these reasons, he will be very difficult to replace. Local Iraqi jihadis will not have the stature, contacts or trust that Zarqawi possessed. Al Qaeda’s leadership will look upon the Baathists converts skeptically. The indigenous Al Qaeda fighters may not trust foreign Al Qaeda members and will be resistant to foreigners taking control of the organization.

It is interesting to look at the potential heirs to al Qaeda in Iraq, as it can illustrate the degree of fractionalization within the organization. There is a power struggle between the domestic Iraqi members (both the Islamists and Baathists) and the foreign elements. The following is a list of the names being bandied about for Zarqawi’s successor (based on reports by Adnkronos International and Dan Darling, additional background links are inserted if available).

The Iraqi Princes:

· Abu Maysira al-Iraqi – The chief of media wing of al Qaeda in Iraq

· Abu Darda al-Iraqi – The chief of operations in Baghdad province.

· Abu Azzam al-Iraqi – A local commander in Anbar province and member of Zarqawi’s Jamaat al-Tawhid wa’l-Jihad. He was responsible for murdering various leaders of the Anbar province last summer.

· Abu Sad al-Duleimi – A local commander in Anbar province.

· Abdul Hadi al-Iraqi – A senior al Qaeda leader who is reportedly Zarqawi’s liaison to bin Laden.

· Izzat Ibrahim al-Douri – The former vice chairman of Saddam’s Baathist Revolutionary Command Council. He swore fealty to Zarqawi last year and commands a significant element of the Baathist/al Qaeda converts. H has significant links in Syria and is an important source of funding for al Qaeda in Iraq.

· Abu Talha – A leader in Ansar al-Islam operating out Mosul in northern Iraq. Update: Scratch Abu Talha, he has been captured on June 16, 2005.

The Foreign Princes:

· Suleiman Khalid DarwishAccording to the Jamestown Foundation he is “a Syrian who is also known as Abud al-Ghadiya” and “was a companion of al-Zarqawi in the al Qaeda training camps al-Zarqawi ran in Herat” He is purportedly Zarqawi’s chief of Jamaat al-Tawhid wa’l-Jihad in Syria. Update: Scratch Darwish, he has been killed on June 26th, 2005 in Qaim.

· Abud Hafs al-Qarni (al-Gerni) – A Saudi Arabian and purportedly a member of a clan that is know for cranking out Islamists.

We have already witnessed the struggle between Abu Maysira al-Iraqi and Abud Hafs al-Qarni, as the latter attempted to usurp command by issuing a statement via the web. It will be interesting to see how al-Douri makes a play for control. If this does indeed happen, there may be a serious bloodbath between the Baathists and jihadis.

So who are the likely successors to the throne? If I had to guess whom al Qaeda would appoint to lead the organization in Iraq, it would be Suleiman Khalid Darwish. His ties to Zarqawi and work in the training camps in Afghanistan would lend him a degree of trust from bin Laden and Company. The most important trait he possesses is command of al-Tawhid in Syria. He has regional ties, and as reports indicate the jihad is being directed mainly through Syria, he likely has the regional knowledge and contacts to maintain some degree of coordination with the internal and external supply lines across the Syrian border.

The backups would be Abu Maysira al-Iraqi and Abu Azzam al-Iraqi. Maysira is an Iraqi established in the chain of command with intimate knowledge of the organization. Running the media wing gives him a powerful platform and likely contacts with al Qaeda’s international organization. Azzam is a ‘domestic’ member of al Qaeda in Iraq, also a member of al-Tawhid, and has shown a penchant for brutality and cunning while operating in the Anbar province. Like Zarqawi, he is a fighting commander, and has likely earned the respect of his peers.

All of this is of course speculation until Zarqawi’s death is confirmed. It can be assured that Zarqawi’s death cannot be hidden for long. The senior leaders of al Qaeda in Iraq will quickly know of his absence, and will work to shore up their power base and assume command.

The longer it takes for a leader to emerge from the pack, the more assured we can be that there is a serious struggle for control is taking place. And infighting amongst jihadis is always a brutal process. The power of the sword is not held in reserve for their external enemies alone; internal enemies also fall under the knife when the time comes for it. All the better.


The assumptions made in this post are based on open source information only as well as readings on al Qaeda’s history. I am not an intelligence analyst, nor am I in the employ of any government or private organization. I do not have access to classified intelligence. There is very little information to go on with some of the al Qaeda in Iraq lieutenants, so I am basing the choice of Suleiman Khalid Darwish, and secondary choices Abu Maysira al-Iraqi and Abu Azzam al-Iraqi based on the profile of al Qaeda commanders in other theaters. Experience, contacts, leadership, fighting ability, field command, ruthlessness, cunning, trust and devotion to the cause are all valued traits, and each of these men appear to possess a measure these.

Bill Roggio is a Senior Fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and the Editor of The Long War Journal.


  • Rumble: Zarqawi dead

    Egyptian blogger Hammorabi has been accurate in the past; ex: he led on the news of Zarqawi being wounded. More telling to me, however, is Al Qaeda’s claim via Reuters that is peachy-keen and Zarqawi is in the pink. Head

  • Marlin says:

    There is an interesting note in The Daily Star today that the pan-Arab daily Al-Hayat reported that U.S. Army commanders want a special 10-kilometer-long buffer zone to be created on the Iraq-Syria border to stop foreign fighters from entering Iraq.
    “U.S. military operations in Euphrates river towns near the Syrian border are intended to clear the area of insurgents so they can establish the buffer zone,” diplomatic sources said from London.
    The U.S. military in Baghdad was unable to immediately confirm the report.
    Rebels down U.S. chopper as troops seal off Baghdad

  • Zarqawi Dead! – Update

    Check out his blog for more in-depth analysis of those who might succeed Zarqawi.

  • zeppenwolf says:

    Questions remain about the impact Zarqawi’s loss would have on al Qaeda in Iraq.

    Well, one thing’s for sure I guess: if we waxed him, that’s a good thing. 🙂

    Q: If “they” knew that he was dead, would they immediately publish the fact, (screaming about what a great martyr he was, etc), or would they keep it under wraps until his successor was “named”? IOW, does lack of an “official” obit mean that we are confident he is still breathing?

  • al Qaeda in Iraq: Next in Line

    The Times Online reports Zarqawi was seriously wounded after he fled the battlefield during Operation Matador. According to an ‘insurgent commander’; “Shrapnel went in between the right shoulder and his chest, ripped it open and…

  • Potential Zarqawi Successors

    The fate of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi is unknown today, contradicted by different statements from varying sources that report everything from his death, to a full recovery for the terrorist mastermind. One thing we do know is that Bill Roggio at the Fourth …

  • Justin B says:

    I think it means that they do not have the body. Until we have a cold dead body in our hands, we can only theorize. How many times has OBL “been wounded” or “been killed” only to show up with a new videotape.

    Uday and Qsay and the pictures of them were needed to reassure the Iraqi public that they were no longer in control. AZ is not dead until there is a corpse.

  • Tom Murphy says:

    It almost seem that the anti-Bush, Anti-Military, anti-American, anti-war…… are worried that Zarqawi’s death could have a major impact on the insurgency. They are constanly pointing out that the death will not have an impact on the insurgency. Its like they are trying to convince themselves. Why are they so worried? Could it be that the insurgency was not run by anti-american Iraqis but by foriegn terrorist. If this is the case then this would prove once and for all that this was the right war, at the right time, at the right place. PS To all U.S. military, past and present, thank you for your service. You are all my heros. God bless America.

  • Jim Hoft says:

    Bill- That is some incredible reporting you have there. I am impressed. I’ve decided you’ve either done some damn good research or infiltrated the upper echelons of the AlQaeda network. Interesting news.

  • Monday Winds of War: May 30/05

    Memorial Day Tribute; Zarqawi roundup; King Fahd; France, the EU, and ‘non’ mean ‘oui’?; Shift in war effort; NATO’s punch; Iran Reports; Lebanese politics; Palestinian prisoner release; Mexican antiterror commandos turn; AQ in Algeria; More problems i…

  • Bill Roggio says:

    Defintely not #2, Jim.
    zeppenwolf, I don’t think the news cold be suppressed, especially if there is conflict to replace him. Also, based on the ‘chatter’ overheard after various deaths of al Qaeda leaders inteh past, I don’t think this can be kept under wraps for long. That should give us confirmation. My guess is al Qaeda will not make an offical notice until he is replaced, but we will know beforehand.

  • Zarqawi Rumorline: Dead?

    Zarqawi is rumored to be dead and buried in a cemetery in Fallujah.

  • Saif al-Adel, Zarqawi, al Qaeda and Iran

    The links and relationships between Saif al-Adel, Zarqawi, al Qaeda and the Islamic Republic of Iran are there for all to see. Plus, my prediction on Zarqawi’s successors and a juicy Zarqawi rumor.

  • The Demise of Abu Talha

    The Coalition nabs Abu Talha, a dangerous operative, and trusted aide and potential successor to Zarqawi.

  • No 2 Al-Qaeda in Iraq Dead as a Rock

    Man the good news just keeps coming today, about time. CBSNEWS.The No. 2 al Qaeda leader in Iraq was killed Sunday night, U.S. officials say. Abu Azzam, reportedly the deputy to Abu Musab al Zarqawi, was shot during a house…

  • No 2 Al-Qaeda in Iraq Dead as a Rock

    Man the good news just keeps coming today, about time. CBSNEWS.The No. 2 al Qaeda leader in Iraq was killed Sunday night, U.S. officials say. Abu Azzam, reportedly the deputy to Abu Musab al Zarqawi, was shot during a house…

  • Hundreds of loyalists and benefactors of Saddam Hussein’s regime have been found working with or for al Qaeda in Iraq

    These captures and kills demonstrate the ideological divide between “secular”


Islamic state



Al shabaab

Boko Haram